Should the Red Sox Consider Signing Released Former MVP 1B? Following the release of former MVP first baseman Miguel Cabrera by the Detroit Tigers, speculation has arisen about whether the Boston Red Sox should pursue signing him. The 39-year-old veteran has a storied career, winning the Triple Crown in 2012 and earning 11 All-Star selections. Pros of Signing Cabrera * Power Hitting: Cabrera is still a dangerous hitter with plenty of power. In 2022, he hit 18 home runs in just 396 plate appearances. * Experience and Leadership: Cabrera brings a wealth of experience to any team. He has been a key figure in the Tigers’ lineup for over a decade and has played in multiple postseasons. * Mentorship: Cabrera could provide valuable mentorship to young players on the Red Sox roster, especially at first base. Cons of Signing Cabrera * Age and Health: Cabrera is entering his 20th MLB season and has shown signs of decline in recent years. He missed significant time in 2022 due to injuries. * Position: Cabrera has predominantly played first base throughout his career, but the Red Sox currently have a solid option there in Triston Casas. * Restricted Role: Given his age and health, Cabrera would likely have to accept a part-time role, which may not be ideal for a player of his stature. Potential Fit with the Red Sox If the Red Sox do pursue Cabrera, it would likely be as a designated hitter or part-time first baseman. He could provide a veteran presence and occasional power boost to a lineup that is led by young stars like Rafael Devers and Xander Bogaerts. However, it is important to note that the Red Sox already have several designated hitters on their roster, including J.D. Martinez and Alex Verdugo. Additionally, they have invested heavily in Casas at first base and would be reluctant to block his development. Conclusion The decision of whether or not to sign Miguel Cabrera is a complex one for the Red Sox. He could provide some value as a veteran power hitter and mentor, but his age, health, and restricted role must be taken into consideration. Ultimately, the Red Sox will need to weigh the pros and cons carefully before making a decision.Houston Astros Release Jose Abreu; Should the Red Sox Sign Him?
Houston Astros Release Jose Abreu; Should the Red Sox Sign Him? With Triston Casas sidelined with a rib injury, the Boston Red Sox have struggled to find a consistent replacement at first base. Having tried and failed with Garrett Cooper, Dominic Smith, and Bobby Dalbec, the Red Sox may consider acquiring Jose Abreu, who was recently released by the Houston Astros. Abreu’s Past Accomplishments Abreu, 37, had a successful nine-year career with the Chicago White Sox. He earned three Silver Slugger Awards, three All-Star nominations, and the American League MVP award during his tenure with the South Side team. Recent Struggles After signing a three-year contract with the Astros in 2022, Abreu’s performance declined. In 35 games this season, he has a low batting average of .124 and a poor OPS of .361. His power numbers have also dwindled, hitting only two home runs in 2024. Defensive Concerns Abreu’s defense has also been a concern throughout his career. He has made 80 errors at first base, including three this season. Potential Fit for the Red Sox As a short-term fill-in until Casas returns, Abreu could be an option for the Red Sox. He has the experience and past success needed to contribute offensively. Limitations to Consider However, the Red Sox should not expect Abreu to return to his MVP form. His recent struggles, both offensively and defensively, indicate that he is past his prime. Comparison to Other Options Compared to the other players the Red Sox have tried at first base, Abreu’s offensive production is slightly better than Dominic Smith’s (.216 batting average, .641 OPS). Conclusion While Abreu could provide a temporary solution for the Red Sox at first base, they should not expect him to be a long-term answer. His age, declining performance, and defensive limitations make him a less than ideal option. The Red Sox may be better off exploring other available players or waiting for Casas to return from injury.
Former MVP first baseman Jose Abreu was released by the Chicago White Sox on Friday, and the Boston Red Sox are reportedly considering signing him. Abreu, 35, is a three-time All-Star and two-time Silver Slugger who won the AL MVP award in 2020. He has been a durable and productive hitter throughout his career, averaging 30 home runs and 100 RBIs per season. The Red Sox have a need for a first baseman after trading away Eric Hosmer to the Chicago Cubs last month. Abreu would be a significant upgrade over Hosmer, and he would give the Red Sox a much-needed power bat in the middle of their lineup. However, Abreu is also a free agent, and he will likely command a high salary. The Red Sox have already spent a lot of money this offseason, so they may not be willing to give Abreu the contract he is seeking. If the Red Sox do not sign Abreu, they could consider other options at first base, such as free agent Josh Bell or trade target Matt Olson. However, Abreu is the best first baseman available on the market, and he would be a major addition to the Red Sox lineup.
